Robot Or Human?

Canon EF-S - BlackCanon EF-S - BlackNikon F - BlackPentax K - BlackSigma SA - BlackSony A-mount - Black

SLRgear ReviewSeptember 5, 2012by Andrew Alexander

Announced in February 2010, the Sigma 17-50mm ƒ/2.8 EX DC OS HSM provides third-party competition in the short zoom lens market. This is the first zoom lens produced by Sigma in this range that provides both a fixed maximum aperture & optical image stabilization.

Bạn đang xem: Robot or human?

Designed for the APS-C sized camera bodies, the lens provides an effective field of view of 27 - 80mm (Canon) or 26 - 75mm (Nikon & others). The LH825-03 (583) petal-shaped lens hood ships with the lens. The lens takes 77mm filters & is available now for around $700.

SharpnessThe Sigma 17-50mm ƒ/2.8 OS offers sharp central performance throughout its zoom range, with varying degrees of corner softness. This corner softness is improved as the lens is stopped down, và there are a few points of tack-sharp image quality.

Used wide open at wide angle (17mm, ƒ/2.8) produces the ""worst"" corner softness - but even here it is comparatively light, matched nicely with a generous central area which is very sharp. As the lens is stopped down this corner softness abates gracefully, offering excellent sharpness by ƒ/5.6 (which is actually the best setting: diffraction limiting appears to lớn set in at ƒ/8, noticeable by ƒ/11). Stopping down to lớn ƒ/16 or ƒ/22 produces light softness across the frame.

The preceding is actually a good descriptor for performance in the other focal lengths, with a single noteworthy observation. Zoomed in to lớn 21mm, 28mm or 50mm, corner performance is actually slightly better at these focal lengths, but there is an interesting deviation at 35mm where we see corners similar lớn those at 17mm. These are small numbers, so it"s doubtful that you will see a meaningful impact in real-world photography, but it"s interesting to lớn note.

The sharpest point for this lens appears to lớn be 50mm at ƒ/8, where performance is essentially tack-sharp across the frame.

Chromatic AberrationThe Sigma 17-50mm ƒ/2.8 produces CA of the magenta-green variety, noticeable in areas of high contrast, and predominantly in the extreme corners. It"s mostly significant when the lens is used wide open, though zooming in does appear khổng lồ limit its presence.

Shading (""Vignetting"")Corner shading isn"t a huge factor with the Sigma 17-50mm, producing (at its most notable) extreme corners which are just over a half-stop darker than the center of the frame, when the lens is used at 17mm & ƒ/2.8. Other focal lengths used at ƒ/2.8 produce around a third of a stop darker corners; other apertures vày not produce any significant corner shading.

DistortionDistortion is typical for a wide-angle zoom lens; barrel distortion when zoomed khổng lồ wide, approaches no distortion in the middle, and gets a bit of pincushion distortion at the telephoto end. At its worst, distortion is around 0.75% barrel when used at 17mm. The distortion is fairly linear, và meets at the zero-distortion point at around 24mm. After that it"s pincushion distortion in the corners: about -0.3%. You can turn your curves back into straight lines easily with most image processing software.

Autofocus OperationThe Sigma 17-50mm ƒ/2.8 OS is designated as an HSM (hypersonic motor) lens, but it doesn"t chia sẻ the full implementation of what we"ve come lớn expect from Sigma"s HSM lenses. Specifically, it doesn"t feature full-time manual override, so if you want lớn override autofocus results you must first disengage the autofocus. Due to the lens" short focus throw, focusing is quite quick, at around one second to lớn focus from close-focus khổng lồ infinity, và the lens makes very little noise in the process. Attached 77mm filters will not rotate while focusing.

MacroThe lens offers fair macro performance: 0.2x magnification, with a minimum close-focusing distance of 28cm (just under one foot).

Build unique and HandlingThe Sigma 17-50mm ƒ/2.8 OS features an all-black, all-plastic construction; parts of the lens are coated with Sigma"s rubberized coating, which offers good traction. There are two switches on the lens, one to activate or deactivate image stabilization, & one lớn enable or disable autofocusing. The lens features a distance scale, but doesn"t offer a depth-of-field scale. The lens mount is metal, và the 77mm filter threads are plastic. The aperture is made up of seven curved diaphragm blades, which should offer pleasing out-of-focus background elements.

The focus ring is mounted at the kết thúc of the lens, 3/8-inch wide and composed of raised rubber ribs. As mentioned, the focusing range of the ring is fairly small, only 45 degrees, making manual focusing a bit tedious. We found that the focus ring has very little dampening, letting it turn very freely. The focusing throw is bounded on either side by hard stops. The front element doesn"t rotate while focusing.

Xem thêm: Review Gh Creation Nhật Bản Có Tốt Không, Gh Creation Ex Thuốc Tăng Chiều Cao Của Nhật

The zoom ring is the larger of the two, 3/4-inch wide, also composed of large raised rubber ribs. There are around 45 degrees of rotation in the zoom ring, và a nice màn chơi of resistance lớn the ring; not too tight, and not too loose. There"s no evidence of zoom creep, but Sigma does include a zoom lock to lớn fix the lens at 17mm so the lens will not extend while dangling on your neck strap.

The Sigma 17-50mm f/2.8 OS employs Sigma"s optical stabilization. In our testing of it, we noted 2, if not 2 50% stops of hand-holding improvement: kiểm tra our IS test above for further detail.

The included lens hood (LH825-03 583) is of the petal-shaped design, adding a further 1 một nửa inches lớn the overall length of the lens. The interior of the hood is deeply ribbed khổng lồ reduce the impact of any stray light entering the front element, & the hood can be reversed onto the lens for storage.


Tamron 17-50mm ƒ/2.8 XR Di II VC LD Aspherical IF SP AF ~$650Tamron"s design has been around a while: Sigma"s offering tests as slightly better, with better results for sharpness & corner shading. Operationally, they are about the same.

Sigma 18-50mm ƒ/2.8-4.5 DC OS HSM ~$400If you don"t need the constant f/2.8 aperture, Sigma offers a slightly less expensive variable aperture lens which also tests very well.

Canon EF-S 17-55mm ƒ/2.8 IS USM ~$1,150Canon"s offering in this category is about twice as expensive, và offers similar if slightly better performance than the Sigma. Operationally the autofocus system is much better và potentially the build chất lượng as well.

Nikon 17-55mm ƒ/2.8G ED-IF AF-S DX ~$1,250Nikon"s offering in this category is about twice as expensive, và offers similar performance. Nikon"s autofocus system is better than Sigma"s in this case.

Pentax 16-50mm ƒ/2.8 ED AL IF SDM SMC DA* ~$750We haven"t yet tested Pentax"s offering in this category.

Sony 16-50mm f/2.8 DT SSM ~$700Sony"s offering is similar khổng lồ Sigma"s but probably represents a better value: it"s about as sharp, but uses better SSM focusing than Sigma"s implementation of HSM.

ConclusionThere"s no shortage of lenses khổng lồ choose from in the short zoom category, và Sigma"s offering presents an economical alternative to the major manufacturer"s options. Optically it tested well, và it"s not too hard on the pocketbook.

Product Photos


Sample Photos

The VFA target should give you a good idea of sharpness in the center and corners, as well as some idea of the extent of barrel or pincushion distortion and chromatic aberration, while the Still Life subject may help in judging contrast và color. We shoot both images using the mặc định JPEG settings & manual trắng balance of our chạy thử bodies, so the images should be quite consistent from lens khổng lồ lens.

Still Life shot
VFA target

As appropriate, we shoot these with both full-frame & sub-frame bodies, at a range of focal lengths, & at both maximum aperture và ƒ/8. For the ""VFA"" target (the viewfinder accuracy target from Imaging Resource), we also provide sample crops from the center và upper-left corner of each shot, so you can quickly get a sense of relative sharpness, without having to tải về and inspect the full-res images. Khổng lồ avoid space limitations with the layout of our review pages, indexes khổng lồ the kiểm tra shots launch in separate windows.